Review written on 5/1954.
Some say we're never kind enough to Philadelphia Motors. Face it, we don't pull our punches when it comes to vehicle reviews. Just look at what we call the French. That doesn't mean we don't sing praises when someone makes a good Full Sized Sedan like the F8191. So where does the Erie stand in the Full Sized Sedan segment? After spending a few days with the Erie. We have made our judgment.

As always, our first stop with the Philadelphia Motors Erie was the track. This Full Sized Sedan may wow some people. It's certainly has better power and performance than most of its peers. The 155 hp @ 4082RPMs 4976 cc V4 engine is able to put a healthy amount of rubber on the road. When you do this properly, you're able to propel the Erie to a top speed of 97 mph and drag times of 19.145s 0 to 60 mph are a breeze. With 160 lb-ft of torque we were able to drag 22 lbs on our test trailer. So it can move your spare junk! Philadelphia Motors really did well with the Erie when it comes to the track. I certainly think this vehicle is better than most in its class. Compared to its peers in the Full Sized Sedan class the Philadelphia Motors Erie selling point should not be driveability. The Erie offers bare bones handling. There is just enough grip in the wheels to keep you from flying off the side of a cliff... But not much. On the track, it is not much better.

While the Philadelphia Motors Erie won't win any awards, It won't turn heads, and it certainly doesn't have a wow factor. The Erie does have a very well design interior. It may not be top end, but it is more than enough for long trips and everyday drivers. It makes you feel good about life. Without feeling pompous.

Inside the Philadelphia Motors Erie it feels like they could add an extra row of seats. There is enough room to even lay down, which is amazing! The 49 cu-ft of cargo and passenger space ensures that you always have plenty of room to do whatever it is you need to do. And that makes us happy.

It may not be much in this day and age, but the Philadelphia Motors Erie is above its class average when we looked at the physical quality of the machine. While other manufacturers cut corners, Philadelphia Motors looks to keep their image and public perception high. They do a good job at that with the Erie.

The Philadelphia Motors Erie is a reliable car that we would trust our dear old grandmother with. These things are almost bulletproof.

The Philadelphia Motors Erie's fuel economy is impressive, but not in a good way. The Erie's 15.3 mpg is one of the worst in class. This might not be troublesome when you look at the numbers, but it will be when you actually have to pay for it.

With some focus on safety, Philadelphia Motors Erie has been able to outshine most in its class. It almost makes you believe the marketing hype that Philadelphia Motors does actually believe in the safety and security of your family.

In the end the Philadelphia Motors Erie provide decent value for the money. It's not the best car in the Full Sized Sedan segment, but it won't disappoint. You could do a lot worse. If this model appeals to you I see no reason to dissuade you from it.